Monday, February 16, 2009

Nell entry!

My first impression of Nell was I thought she had language and communication deficiencies. I even thought Nell had her own language since she was speaking differently. But as the movie continued, we see that Nell’s way of communication is due to the fact that her mom suffered a stroke. She was imitating her mom since that was the only one she lived with and since her sister died, she had nobody else to communicate with.

The observations made by the doctors were obviously different approaches. Paula’s approach was more of a scientific and psychological observation. She took Nell as a subject and looked at her as another subject for her field. Her colleagues even suggested that Nell should be taken away from her home and be studied closely. Paula makes Nell like another patient and throughout her time living in the forest she doesn’t take the time to come out and communicate with Nell. Because of this, she doesn’t have a personal relationship with Nell and doesn’t even make an effort to get to know her.

Unlike Paula, Jerry took Nell as a personal approach because he empathized with her. As discussed in class we clearly see that Jerry humanizes Nell and didn’t want to make her to be another subject for study. He put himself in her shoes so he can relate and get to know who she is by a first hand account. Jerry grows to respect Nell as a friend since she has no one else with her. Their relationship grows because he helps her come outside during the daytime and even accompanies her during her evening swims. We can see that the guardian angel title that Nell gives her is personal for Nell because Jerry protects her. He gives her the chance to live her life and Jerry takes his time to understand her.

If I were in that position, I would do the same thing as Jerry because Nell’s lifestyle is not common. Being a friend to her is the most important since she lost her mother and her twin sister who played a big role in her life.

The links of symbolic interactionism in Nell are clearly seen. In the beginning of the movie, Nell was labeled as “crazy” because of her strange lifestyle and reactions to everyday life. Nell also created her own reality and this is where we see that she builds herself in her world when she remembers her sister. She runs around in the forest and we can see her imagining her playing.

2 comments:

  1. I analyzed the film a little different, you can read if you want.. but I think you need to understand that the language is more than just influenced from the stroke... The film is based about, Idioglossia the play and definition.. so to say. Anyways, the girls also developed their own way to communicate... thus, Nell still communicates with herself, in that way. The Creole, I would also call it, would be derived from ENGLISH and the mothers speech impediment from the stroke. And.. the skeleton she picked up of her sister seemed pretty big... whose to say that she died recently, thus she was communicating with her sister for long periods of time. And Nell KNOWS her sister is dead, thats within her reality, but she has memories, like we do... ! I feel like she has more of a childish mentality... daydreaming and all...playing pretend... creating realities out of the stories her mother told her... remember when you were young? Were you scared to go out at night? If so, why are you able to go out at night now? For me... when I was like 5.. my parents told me the boogie man would get me...so I created my own reality of the boogie man, and never left my home at night. Imagine, a five year old walking around in the middle of the night. Thats what my parents felt was right... were they crazy? I don't think so... I think it was actually the best idea now..
    And for Nells mother... she was raped, had to kids, she created realities for her children because she didn't want them to get raped... she let them communicate, just only with each other within the house. Would we call that crazy? I would... but who am I to judge... it's her life, her way of living.

    Also, I dont think Jerry has any idea what it's like to be in Nell's shoes... he's never been in that situation, at least from the information we've learned. Obviously his motivation is different, I think it's the reality he created for himself from that letter the dead mom left, but those are just my thoughts. Anyways... feel free to comment on my blog. xox

    ReplyDelete
  2. Frankie & Shayna: great initial discussion! I think you both make some valid points. Yes, Nell the movie is LOOSELY based on the play Idioglossia. There have been several examples of idioglossia (speaking one's own language or private language) over the years, which brings me to the following question:

    Does Nell's use and knowledge of a language created as a child with her twin "keep" her childish? Has her inability to expand her vocabulary (because of isolation and death of her sibling) limit her experience?

    ReplyDelete